• 541.482.5189
  • 866-762-7879 (sales)
  • 877.SMARTS.7 (customer service)

How to Pitch Insurance Stories to the Media

April 18, 2012

 

First things first: A pitch isn’t the same as a press release. A press release is a self-contained news story that you provide to a number of news outlets, which, if you’re lucky, reporters will rewrite so that your release fits their style and space — and you can run the release as-is on your own website.

News Reporters Interviewing a Woman in a Suit Accompanied by PhotographersA pitch, on the other hand, is the planting of an idea; an invitation to a reporter to write a story, or to an editor to assign one, with you as a key — but not necessarily the only — source.

It most likely takes some angle on your local market and the role you play in it. And while you send a press release to all your local or regional media, you make your pitch to one journalist.

“It takes some careful studying of the news media on your part to know whom to target, understand what journalists are interested in, and when to make your pitch,” said Jennifer Wezensky, president of JW Public Relations, a national boutique PR firm based near Kalamazoo, Mich.

Here are nine ways you can sell a story to the media and get some free, positive publicity:

  1. Study the Media. Do the media outlets have reporters who specialize in financial services, or are there general business reporters? Is there a financial or business section in your local newspaper or regional magazines? Do they run stories about health, life, personal or commercial insurance topics?  Learn the news your media report, their editorial calendars, and the general rhythm of their coverage. Especially note recurring slow news days when there seems to be a lot of non-local fill-copy in print or on air.
  2. Build Your Target List. This isn’t your media list with just names, phone numbers and e-mail addresses. Take note of reporters whose styles you like or who seem more informed about insurance and related financial topics than the average general assignment reporter — or on the flip side, a young reporter who has skills but needs good contacts, such as you. Get a sense of what certain editors like to cover, and note that in your contact list. Make personal contact with reporters at a meeting or community function to put a face to the byline, and plant the seed in their minds of using you as a potential news source.
  3. Find Fresh Angles. Some topics tend to repeat themselves, and reporters struggle to find new ways to write about them. This can be particularly true in feature stories in home, financial and business sections of newspapers and magazines, where assignments are often pegged to the seasons. Give a fresh angle for one of these stories, and you could become a reporter’s hero.
  4. Give Context to Marketing, Legislative, Judicial or Regulatory Developments. Pitch an idea that interprets how these changes will affect costs and insurance coverages, locally or nationally.
  5. Put a Human Face on a Story. It doesn’t have to be your face. Yes, your pitch should put you and your business in the story. But suggest other sources besides yourself for the story idea, because the reporter is going to need them.
  6. Don’t Make Your News Pitch a Sales Call. Be straightforward and factual in your pitch and explain why it makes a good news story. The same issue needs to be addressed for a pitch as it does for a press release: why your story is important to the reader or viewer, not just you.
  7. Don’t Duck Bad News. In fact, a great time to pitch a story is with controversial regulatory actions, legal decisions and legislation. While reporters struggle to find someone who will talk about the issue, you come forward with your take on how to get through hard times. If you pitch a story on how to respond to the latest crisis, you’ll get good news coverage, and reporters will start calling you.
  8. Pitch by E-Mail. E-mail gives reporters an easy reference they can file away if it arrives on a hectic day. And that can be any day. Avoid sending an e-mail pitch on Fridays, particularly to newspapers where editors and reporters are putting the final touches on Sunday feature sections. Mondays aren’t so hot either, as they catch up with all their e-mail from Friday and the weekend. Tuesdays are often best.
  9. Keep It Concise and Casual. This is a one-on-one communication. You want to get to the point of your pitch, but you also want to come off as friendly and easy to talk to. After all, that’s the point. You want the reporter to call you for quotes. Follow up your pitch with a second e-mail or a phone call a couple of days later, and ask the reporter what he thought of the story idea.

Thanks to Eric Adams, who writes our Real Estate Digest newsletter for title insurers and real estate brokers, for writing the basic material for this week’s column.

Leave a Reply

What is 3 + 7 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)
  • Popular Insurance Marketing Blog Posts

  • Blog Posts

    Subscribe to our Blog

  • Insurance Newsletter Testimonials

  • "Very rarely do you find an organization like SmartsPro that truly understands the industry that they serve. How do they prove it? Through clear and concise monthly content. I would confidently recommend James Whitaker and his publishing team to anyone but my competition!”

    — Ryan Liabenow,
    President & Client Relations,
    Webber Benefits Group,
    Bezonia, Mich.

  • "I really appreciate the quality of your newsletters. I've worked in other industries where good content is fairly easy to find, but in this industry for some reason, that's not often the case. We're proud to put our name on the content that SmartsPro Marketing provides us."

    — Will McDonald,
    Director of Marketing & Client Relations,
    MFG Benefits,
    Reno, Nev.

  • "We are very impressed with the quality of the Newsletter and how clear and precise the PPACA articles are. Thank you!"

    — Ann Tyler,
    Business Manager,
    Boys & Tyler Financial Group,
    Eden Prairie, Minn.
  • “We try to ‘touch’ our clients in a number of ways throughout the year. We sometimes put on seminars; we send birthday and sympathy cards and calendars, and we talk to our clients on the phone regularly. And of course we send our newsletter out monthly. We want our clients to keep us top of their mind."

    — Aimee Ouimette,
    Agent,
    Wisconsin Benefit Planning, Inc.,
    Minocqua, Wis.
  • “Upon sending the first issue of our SmartsPro newsletter for our agency, we received positive responses from our clients. The information in the newsletter is dependable, relevant and interesting. It makes our agency shine above the competition in terms of the value-added services we provide our clients. And it establishes for our clients a sense of value to our agency. This option was definitely a win-win decision.”

    — Wendy Vanderwater,
    Group Benefits Producer,
    Threlkeld & Company Insurance,
    Tyler, Tex.
  • "We've been a Smart's client newsletter customer for over ten years. We find the newsletters to be very informative. They provide a great way to touch base with our clients and prospects. I'm a firm believer in sending them to clients because when they read about the coverages they need, they call us to get them."

    — Van Maroevich,
    President and CEO,
    MOC Insurance Services,
    San Francisco, Calif.
  • “I really think my newsletters have bumped up my credibility a couple of notches,”

    — Susan Emery,
    Emery Benefit Solutions,
    Auburn Hills, Mich.
  • "We've been very pleased with the professionalism of the SmartsPro newsletters. They allow us to keep our name in front of customers and prospects by providing useful risk management and insurance information they can use to help them run their businesss better."

    — Scott Crawford,
    Sr. Vice President,
    J. Smith Lanier & Co.,
    Atlanta, Ga.
  • "We struggled for over a year to develop our own content before we found our SmartsPro newsletter. Now we could not imagine not having it. It is a great resource for our clients and we get positive feedback from them. It's an incredible way to stay 'top of mind' with our clients."

    — Michael Bakonyi, REBC,
    Managing Partner,
    Employer Solutions Group,
    Austin, Tex.
  • "[Newsletters are ]… a great way to get your name in front of clients. If people constantly see something, that's a way to make them always think [about you] in regards to all their needs."

    — Linda Radcliffe
    Marketing Coordinator,
    GCG Financial,
    Bannockburn, Ill.
  • "The thought of creating from scratch a regular-scheduled customer newsletter, complete with industry updates and relevant articles as well as my insurance brokerage firm's news, is daunting. If I didn't have Smart's Publishing to rely on for the researching, writing and laying-out of our Insurance Buyer's News newsletter, all my time would go toward its production.

    What I like most is its flexibility; I can include as many or as few articles and pictures of my own as I want. If my company has news or an event that I'd like to share with customers, then I can customize our newsletter with self-written articles. Or I can leave it entirely up to Smart's Publishing to produce my company's newsletter, and it's sure to include timely information that is valuable to our customers."

    — Christina MaGee
    Higginbotham & Associates,
    Fort Worth, Tex.
  • " It couldn’t be easier! I invest only about an hour per issue, and we get a high-quality newsletter, customized with our own articles, staff bios and photos, mailed out to our clients."

    — Scott Addis,
    President,
    The Addis Group,
    King of Prussia, Penn.
  •